A woman writes her will. Stock photo by Getty Images
Some people prefer to keep things simple when making a will. It doesn’t get much simpler than a holographic will, but be warned: they’re attractively simple, but not always legal.
A holographic will is one that’s written and signed entirely in the testator’s own hand and unsigned by any witnesses.
Holographic wills are easy to produce, don’t come with any costs, and let you express your last wishes exactly how you want. But they also carry risks.
Most importantly, some Canadian courts don’t accept them as valid. Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, and Nunavut don’t recognize holographic wills.
Neither does British Columbia, although some recent changes to provincial law allow a court to “cure deficiencies” in a will that’s technically invalid. Basically, if a court finds a normally invalid will actually represents a person’s “testamentary intentions,” it might approve the will.
Those provincial limitations also apply to codicils — the additional notes or documents that amend a will. If a valid will comes with an invalid codicil, it’s the original document that wins out.
For example, someone’s will could leave their entire estate to their spouse. Then they get divorced and, instead of officially updating the will, just add a handwritten note that the estate now goes to someone else. Depending on the jurisdiction, that handwritten update could be invalid.
Overall, since holographic wills are a homemade product, they’re very likely to have errors or omissions that could compromise the distribution of your estate.
Some of the common mistakes in holographic wills include:
- Failing to name an executor: this means a court appoints one for you, and maybe not the person you want. It can lead to family squabbles and court battles.
- Failing to name guardians: similarly, this means a court, not you, decides who fills this important role.
- Not disposing of the entire estate: formal wills usually include a “residuary clause” that says what happens with the residue of your estate — the assets left over after court fees, taxes and other costs. This is easy to overlook in your homemade will.
- Ambiguity: wording that’s clear to you isn’t necessarily clear to others. In one example, an Ontario father left annual payments to his daughter “so long as she continues to reside in Canada.” He didn’t say how long she had to reside for, or if she could take trips abroad. A court invalidated that condition in the will.
If holographic wills are valid in your jurisdiction and you’re determined to write one, do plenty of research to avoid the many common mistakes. Also, discuss it with your executor and beneficiaries to ensure your will and wishes are clear and unambiguous.